ASL Reviews is supported by our readers. We may earn a commission through products (including amazon) purchased using links on this page. Learn More.

Puffy vs Nectar Mattress Comparison

Written by

Serena Scheide, Certified Sleep Science Coach

Last Updated: June 23, 2025

In This Guide

Overview
Construction & Materials
Firmness & Feel
Mattress Performance
Motion Isolation & Edge Support
Ease of Movement
Conclusion

If you’re exploring memory foam mattresses, chances are you’ve come across both Puffy and Nectar. Both brands have carved out strong reputations in the bed-in-a-box world, each offering unique qualities that appeal to different types of sleepers.

Puffy stands out for its cloud-like comfort and cooling features, crafted for those who want a mattress that balances softness with support to keep them cool and comfortable all night. On the flip side, Nectar is loved for its affordable pricing, classic memory foam feel, and unbeatable 365-night sleep trial and Forever warranty, making it a favorite for value-conscious shoppers.

In this comparison, we’ll take a close look at Puffy vs. Nectar across key categories like construction, comfort, support, and temperature regulation so you can find the best match for your sleep needs. Whether you’re a back sleeper needing support or a side sleeper looking for pressure relief, this guide will help you make the right choice.

Mattress Overview

Before diving into the full comparison, here’s a quick look at the top strengths of each mattress in the Puffy vs. Nectar debate:

Puffy Cloud Mattress

The Puffy Cloud is a standout choice for back sleepers, combination sleepers, and anyone dealing with back pain, thanks to its balanced mix of support and comfort. Its medium-firm feel provides a supportive yet responsive surface that keeps sleepers more “on top” of the mattress rather than sinking in. The Puffy Cloud also offers exceptional motion isolation and solid edge support, making it an excellent option for couples.

Nectar Mattress

Nectar’s classic memory foam feel and deep pressure relief make it a perfect fit for side sleepers and those with chronic pain conditions, such as fibromyalgia and arthritis. Its softer, body-contouring foam is ideal for anyone seeking relief from pressure points. Plus, Nectar’s affordability, generous 365-night trial, and Forever warranty make it an exceptional option for budget-conscious shoppers.

Puffy Cloud

Read Review

Nectar

Read Review

Quickview Comparison

Features

Nectar

Puffy Cloud

Type

Memory Foam

All-Foam

Firmness

Medium-Firm (5.5 – 6)

Medium-Firm (6 – 6.5)

Best For

Side and Back Sleepers, Pressure Relief, Budget-Conscious shoppers

Side, Back, & Combination Sleepers, Couples, Back Pain

Trial Period

365 Nights

101 Nights

Warranty

Lifetime Warranty

Price

Around $649 for a Queen

Around $1,049 with discounts

Construction & Materials

When comparing Puffy vs. Nectar mattresses, construction is key to understanding how each one offers its distinct feel. In this section, we’ll break down the layers of both Puffy and Nectar mattresses, emphasizing how their designs influence comfort, support, and overall performance.

Puffy Cloud Mattress Construction

The Puffy Cloud features a 10-inch profile made up of five layers designed to offer a balanced blend of comfort and support:

Stain-Resistant Cloud Cover: The hypoallergenic, OEKO-TEX Standard 100-certified cover is removable and washable, making it easy to keep your mattress fresh and clean.
2″ Cooling Cloud Foam: Gel-infused foam offers a cooling sleep surface, helping to prevent heat buildup throughout the night.
2″ Climate Comfort Foam: This layer provides additional pressure relief while adapting to various sleep positions, enhancing comfort.
6″ Firm Core Support Foam: A high-density base layer ensures stability and durability, offering support for a range of body types and sleep styles.
Grip Base Cover: Keeps the mattress securely in place on your foundation or frame.

The Puffy Cloud’s construction strikes a balance between pressure relief and support, catering particularly well to back sleepers and combination sleepers who appreciate a slightly firmer feel.

Nectar Mattress Construction

Nectar’s recent update has brought slight changes to its all-foam structure, though the mattress retains its classic memory foam feel with a few added benefits:

New Quilted Cooling Cover: This breathable cover improves airflow and keeps the mattress surface cool, adding a soft, plush feel that enhances overall comfort. It is OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certified, ensuring it’s free from harmful substances. Unlike Puffy, the Nectar mattress cover should never be removed, as doing so will void the warranty.
1″ Therapeutic Memory Foam: This top layer offers pressure relief and contouring, making it especially beneficial for side sleepers.
3″ Transition Layer: This responsive support layer minimizes excessive sinkage, ensuring a smooth transition between the comfort layer and the support base. It also keeps the mattress responsive, making it easier to move without feeling “stuck.”
8″ ActiveSupport Base Layer: The high-density foundational layer provides durable support, minimizes motion transfer, and reinforces edge support, enhancing the mattress’s stability over time.

Nectar’s updated design continues to provide excellent pressure relief and body contouring, making it an ideal choice for budget-conscious shoppers, side sleepers, and those with specific pain relief needs.

Mattress Certifications

Both the Puffy Cloud and Nectar mattresses are constructed with CertiPUR-US certified foams, ensuring they are free from harmful chemicals and meet rigorous safety standards. Additionally, the covers of both mattresses are OEKO-TEX standard 100 certified, meaning the textiles are tested for harmful substances, offering added peace of mind for health-conscious consumers. For a deeper look into these certifications, explore our mattress certifications guide.

Firmness & Feel

When it comes to finding a mattress with the right firmness level, both Puffy and Nectar offer a comfortable experience for side and back sleepers. However, each mattress has unique characteristics that cater to different sleep needs and preferences.

Puffy Cloud Mattress Firmness & Feel

The Puffy Cloud mattress has a medium-firm feel, rating around 6 to 6.5 on the firmness scale, which is ideal for back sleepers and combination sleepers. Its responsive layers offer a balanced mix of support and comfort, making it easy to move without feeling stuck. For individuals with back pain, Puffy’s balanced support and gentle cushioning help maintain spinal alignment, making it an excellent choice for pain relief.

While Puffy is versatile for a range of sleepers, those who sleep primarily on their stomach or need additional support may want to consider a hybrid option like the Puffy Royal which offers enhanced support through its zoned hybrid design.

Nectar Mattress Firmness & Feel

The Nectar mattress has a slightly softer feel, rating between 5.5 and 6, with a traditional memory foam experience that hugs the body. This plush, contouring feel is particularly beneficial for side sleepers, offering relief for the shoulders and hips by evenly distributing weight and alleviating pressure points. Those with chronic pain conditions like fibromyalgia or arthritis may find this deeper contouring especially comfortable.

Due to its softer feel, Nectar may be less suited to heavier individuals or stomach sleepers, who often need more robust support. Nectar’s hybrid options could provide the added firmness these sleepers require. For more choices, see our best hybrid mattresses for options that offer increased durability and support.

Puffy vs Nectar: Mattress Performance

Temperature Regulation

A mattress’s ability to regulate temperature is crucial, especially for hot sleepers. Both Puffy and Nectar have incorporated cooling features to help prevent overheating, though they approach temperature regulation differently.

Puffy Cloud Mattress Cooling

The Puffy Cloud mattress is designed to keep sleepers cool with gel-infused Cooling Cloud Foam and open-cell technology that encourages airflow. This combination helps reduce heat buildup, and because Puffy has a slightly firmer feel, it keeps sleepers more “on top” of the mattress rather than sinking deeply into it. This design gives Puffy an advantage for hot sleepers, as it maintains a cooler, more temperature-neutral sleep surface.

Nectar Mattress Cooling

The Nectar mattress also incorporates cooling technology, with a poly-blend cover featuring cooling polyethylene fibers for added breathability. However, memory foam mattresses—especially those with a deep, contouring feel—are generally more prone to heat retention. Since Nectar provides that signature “hug-like” feel, some sleepers may find it warmer than Puffy. For those who sleep especially hot, adding a cooling accessory like the BedJet climate system or Eight Sleep’s cooling mattress cover can help offset some of the warmth typically associated with memory foam.

Puffy Cloud

Read Review

DreamCloud

Read Review

Motion Isolation & Edge Support

For couples and those sharing a bed, motion isolation and edge support are key performance factors. Puffy and Nectar both perform well for motion isolation, though as all-foam mattresses, edge support has some limitations.

Puffy Cloud Mattress

The Puffy Cloud mattress provides solid motion isolation, absorbing movement effectively to minimize disruptions from a partner’s shifting. This makes it a good option for couples or light sleepers prioritizing uninterrupted rest. Regarding edge support, Puffy does reasonably well for an all-foam mattress, offering a bit more stability around the perimeter than Nectar due to its slightly firmer feel. However, you may still notice some compression, especially when sitting on the edge.

Nectar Mattress

Nectar’s memory foam layers deliver excellent motion isolation, matching Puffy’s ability to limit movement transfer across the mattress. Its deep, contouring foam absorbs motion well, making it a strong choice for couples. In terms of edge support, however, Nectar’s softer, body-hugging foam tends to compress more along the edges, which may be noticeable if you frequently sit or lie near the perimeter.

Note: Both Puffy and Nectar excel at isolating motion, making them an excellent option for couples seeking minimal movement transfer. However, like most all-foam mattresses, they do have some limitations in edge support. If edge stability is a top priority, a hybrid or innerspring mattress may offer better reinforcement along the perimeter, ensuring a sturdier feel.

Ease of Movement

For combination sleepers or anyone who changes positions frequently throughout the night, ease of movement is another important factor. Both Puffy and Nectar offer a unique feel but differ in responsiveness and mobility.

Puffy Cloud

The Puffy Cloud mattress provides a balanced feel, with a medium-firm surface that’s responsive enough to make movement easier. The slightly firmer, more responsive foam layers prevent that “stuck” sensation often associated with memory foam, allowing you to shift positions with ease. This makes Puffy a great choice for combination sleepers or those who don’t want to feel too deeply cradled by their mattress.

Nectar

Nectar’s deep, contouring memory foam creates more of a classic memory foam experience, which can feel slightly more restrictive for those who tend to move around frequently. The foam layers provide a comfortable “hug” that is ideal for side sleepers but may give a slight “stuck-in-the-mud” feel, especially if you’re used to a more responsive surface. While Nectar’s plush feel is great for pressure relief, it may not be as well-suited for combination sleepers who prefer easier mobility.

Puffy vs Nectar: Price, Warranty & Sleep Trial

Puffy Cloud

Sleep Trial: 101-nights
Warranty: Lifetime
Price Range: $599 – $1498 after discounts

Nectar

Sleep Trial: 365-nights
Warranty: Lifetime
Price Range: $349 – $1098 after discounts

Puffy and Nectar both offer exceptional value, with flexible return policies and generous warranties that provide peace of mind. Nectar’s pricing is slightly more budget-friendly, especially for shoppers seeking an affordable memory foam mattress with a longer trial period. Puffy, while a bit more expensive, is competitively priced with the added assurance of a lifetime warranty.

Puffy vs. Nectar: Which is Right for You?

Choosing between Puffy and Nectar comes down to your personal sleep preferences, budget, and specific comfort needs. Here’s a quick recap to help you make the best decision:

Choose Puffy If:

You’re a back sleeper, combination sleeper, or experience back pain, and need a mattress with a medium-firm feel that offers balanced support.
You prefer a sleep surface that keeps you more “on top” rather than deeply cradled, thanks to Puffy’s slightly firmer, more responsive foam layers.

Choose Nectar If:

You’re a side sleeper or have chronic pain conditions like fibromyalgia or arthritis and need a mattress with excellent pressure relief and deep contouring.
You’re looking for a budget-friendly memory foam mattress with an extended 365-night sleep trial and a Forever warranty for added peace of mind.

Final Thoughts

Both Puffy and Nectar are excellent options for couples, with strong motion isolation that minimizes sleep disruptions. While Puffy may perform slightly better for cooling, hot sleepers looking for a mattress that actively cools may want to explore our best mattresses for cooling for alternatives designed to keep you cooler through the night.