Original Casper Pillow Review

Casper is undoubtedly one of the biggest names in the mattress industry today and for good reason. In addition to their wildly popular mattresses, Casper sells bedding, bases, pillows, lighting, and dog beds. To say we were excited to get our hands on the Casper Pillow was an understatement.

Is it everything we dreamed of? Find out in our Original Casper Pillow review.


  • Machine washable
  • 100% with percale weave
  • Designed for all sleep positions
  • Luxurious hotel feel


  • Not adjustable
  • Makes some noise when moving around
  • A bit expensive

What role does your pillow play in getting a good night's rest?

A lot of importance is placed in finding the perfect mattress and rightfully so! However, your pillow should not be overlooked. What pillow you sleep with can be just as important to your comfort as having the right mattress is. This is especially true if you suffer from upper back and neck pain, or migraines. You may even find your snoring is affected by the pillow you sleep with.

RELATED: The Casper Mattress Review

Construction of the Original Casper Pillow

Casper designed it’s pillow to have a universal appeal. This can be challenging as needs change from one sleep position to the next. However, Casper has attempted to tick as many boxes as possible to help you get a better night’s sleep.

The Original Casper pillow features a pillow-in-pillow design. The inner pillow is designed to offer support while the outer pillow is soft and fluffy for comfort. Both the inner and outer pillow contain low friction, silky polyester fibers that offer pressure-relief while at the same time providing a springy responsiveness.

The pillow features a 2 inch wide gusset that runs along the sides to create additional support and keep the pillow from falling flat. It’s also meant to help keep the neck in better alignment. More on that in a bit!

No more having to flip your pillow to the “cool side”. The outer casing of the pillow is 100% cotton with a breathable percale weave to help keep your pillow cool throughout the night.

The outer pillow has a zip that surrounds 2 sides of the pillow allowing for easy removal of the inner pillow, or for simply fluffing up the insides. Once the inner pillow has been removed you can re-zip the outer pillow and machine wash it cold on a gentle cycle. Tumble dry on low making sure the pillow is 100% dry before removing.

hand holding Casper's pillow-in-pillow design
Casper's pillow-in-pillow design

How does it feel?

I’m accustomed to sleeping on a memory foam pillow so my initial impressions were a bit uncertain. The pillow doesn’t offer the same dense consistency I was used to with my memory foam. In fact, I thought the pillow compressed quite flat and was concerned it wouldn’t be a good match for me. However, after fluffing it up a bit and giving it some time to fully expand I came back to it and my feelings took a 180 degree turn.

It reminded me of a down pillow but with more substance. The pillow cover has a cool, crisp feel that reminds me of a good night’s sleep at a luxury hotel. It’s definitely a pillow you want to snuggle up with.

Now, as much as I enjoyed propping myself up to watch a movie on it, the true test is waking up after 8 hours pain free. Where the Casper pillow really excels is back sleeping. It’s got a medium to medium-soft supportive feel that does a great job of relieving pressure around the back of the head and creating a gentle cradle. Unlike memory foam, the contouring offers a light, fluffy feel and doesn’t sleep hot.

Side sleepers may find the pillow to be just a bit too soft to properly support the neck. Especially if coming from a memory foam pillow. You may be accustomed to a bit of a denser profile. That being said, if you know you prefer a lower profile or softer pillow for side sleeping this could be a great choice. It’s also a great pillow to use in combination with other pillows!

Stomach sleepers may be a bit divided on this pillow. I spend a lot of time sleeping on my stomach and personally loved it for stomach sleeping. The pillow does compress quite a bit so even though it looks quite lofty it doesn’t force your neck uncomfortably upwards. However, if you prefer a pillow with little to no profile you could still find this a bit too full for comfort. That being said, the inner pillow is removable so you could use the outer pillow for just a touch of luxurious softness.

You will notice a bit of a crinkly sound when moving about, though this didn’t bother me (again it reminds me of luxury hotel beds), if you are a light sleeper this might disturb you a bit.

Casper Pillow up close

Bottom Line

Overall it was a surprisingly comfortable pillow that could be a great choice for a lot of people.

The Casper Pillow come in 2 sizes, Standard for $65 and King for $85. They also have a down feather pillow available for $125 and $165.

In the unfortunate case that it is not the right fit for you, Casper does offer a 100 night risk-free sleep trial. If you don’t love it, Casper will issue a full refund.

The Pillow comes with a limited 1 year warranty as well as free shipping and returns when purchased through Casper directly.

You'll love the Casper Pillow if:

  • You are a back or combo sleeper, we felt the pillow really excelled for back sleepers but could be a great fit for all sleepers.
  • You like a fluffy, down like feel.
  • You sleep hot: the pillow is super breathable and sleeps cool.

The Casper Pillow might not be for you if:

  • You are a side sleeper who needs a good amount of support under the neck.
  • You are a stomach sleeper who prefers to sleep on a flatter surface.
  • You want a pillow that allows you to fully customize it.